
My take on the Montreal Canadiens for the 2011-2012 season..
Goaltending:
Carey Price:
His play last year made him a legitimate member of the Vezina trophy conversation. He should have no trouble continuing his excellent play this year. His game in Toronto was fine although he was tagged with the loss. Expect him to play a minimum of 65 games this year. As Price goes, so do the Canadiens. (A+)
Peter Budaj
:
He lost the number one job to Jose Theodore and Colorado was more than happy to let him go as Craig Anderson who replaced Theodore displaced Budaj. He has holes in his game and for a goalie, that’s bad. He could play a max of 20 games but judging from his preseason play, he may get 10-12. Not reassuring. (C)
Defense:
Andrei Markov:
Oft injured Markov should be the general on defense when healthy. I’m thinking that 30 games may be limit this year. I don’t know if he can once again be the number 1 defenseman he once was. Two injuries to the same knee in such quick succession can slow down even the best of players. I hope he can come back to form, but it’s not looking good at the moment. (A-)
P.K. Subban:
Subban should be the general
in waiting but he has to assume the rank earlier than expected. His is still a high risk, high reward type player as he has to learn to control his game and make good decisions. His two errors of judgment against Toronto were the difference and he’s smart enough to know it. His talent in undeniable and he is already a star in the NHL. He is exciting to watch and he could only get better. (A)
Josh Gorges:
A born leader who is also fearless and courageous. He is a 3 or 4 defenseman, can kill penalties well and makes good decision with the puck. He has an uncanny ability to bounce back from a hard check. (B+)
Hal Gill:
PK’s mentor and all around great team guy. His value is on the penalty kill and during the
playoffs. A gentle giant of sorts, he is a great teacher to Subban. Teams need guys like him and I’m happy he’s a hab. (B-)+
Yannick Weber:
In the process of playing himself off the team until Spacek got hurt. A defenceman rele
gated to 4th line forward is not usually a good thing. He has a great shot but that’s all he seems to have. He may be in danger to losing his spot…a spot he was all but guaranteed at the start of training camp. His PP goal against Winnipeg has bought him some time (C)
Chris Campoli:
He came as advertised…injury prone. I like him and his style of play but at his age and physical troubles, can he really be a valuable asset? The jury is out on him, we’ll just have to wait and see. (-)
Raphael Diaz:
Has shown good things when he has played. The best defenseman by far in Switzerland, he still needs to learn the north american game, but he has huge upside and has already supplanted Weber on the depth chart. (B-)
Alexi Emelin:
The biggest news on him this year was that they took the (Y) out of his name. He plays a physical style which is a welcome change to the physical-less habs of recent years. Has the potential to be a good 3-4 man. His problem may be between the years sort of like a certain Andrei Kostitsyn. (B-)
Jaroslav Spacek:
Brought in to help the power play, he doesn’t get to play on it. He is one year older and had slowed down a step. He may be in better shape but he is now a 4-5 at best. Can still help the team but this is surely his last year with the team. (C)
Forwards:
Tomas Plekanec:
The smartest forward on this team, he can do it all. That may be his problem as Jacques Martin uses him too much. Near the end of the season he is too tired to make that much of a difference and he’s non-existant, at least by his standards, during the playoffs. This is no fault of his own, the blame lies on the shoulders of Jacques Martin. I like his use as point man on the PP, lets hope the coach sticks with the expiriment for a few games at least (A)
Michael Cammelleri:
A pure goal scorer who has the image of a selfish player. I want goal scorers to be selfish because they tend to shoot first and ask questions later, something that habs players have lacked recently. (A-)
Eric Cole:
At least he won’t haunt the habs for a while! What the team needed it got in Cole. He is a straight to the net kind of player and his presence gives the Canadiens a chance at 3 good lines. A very good pickup (B+)
Andrei Kostitsyn:

He can break the game open but his problem is the mental fog that won’t clear out of his head. A player t hat will do better elsewhere because he just won’t do it here. So much talent, if only he applied himself more, he could be a star in this league. (C)
David Desharnais:
I must admit that I have a appreciation of all that he has accomplished. I feel that his talents are being wasted on the third line and when Eller comes back, the fourth line. He is stuck behind Gomez as is Eller and that can only hurt him in the long run. He has great vision and makes great passes. Play him with Max Pacioretty or Eric Cole and enjoy the fun to come. (B+)
Brian Gionta:
A warrior in the Saku Koivu mold. A true leader who is being hurt by the presence of Gomez on his line. He was and is the right choice of captain. Not afraid of the corners and front of the net. (A)
Travis Moen:
Aside from yesterday’s goal, I don’t understand his usefulness to the team. I hear he’s great in the room but that does not translate into value on the ice. (C+)
Max Pacioretty:
A budding power forward who will only get better. He is a joy to watch and with Desharnais the sky’s the limit! He shows no ill effects from the Chara hit. (A)
Scott Gomez:
I will not begrudge his salary. His point total was abysmal last season and despite words to the contrary, he has played the same way in the first two games. It’s as if he thinks he has only one option, the pass. His presence on the team hurts Gionta, Eller and Desharnais. I see 40 points at the most for Gomez and that’s just not good enough for a number two center. A failure from day 1 (C-)
Ryan White:
A gutsy player and enery line kind of guy. Useful, he needs to work on his finish. (C)
Lars Eller:
Another good pickup, he has the potential as a number 2 center with gusts to number 1. He is strong with good vision and he, like Pacioretty, can only get better. (B-)
Mathieu Darche:
All teams need a player and person like him. A man who knows what a priviledge it is to play in the NHL. He brings energy to the 4th line and acts like a mentor to the younger ones. (B-)
I do not know enough of Aaron Palushaj or Andreas Enqvist to make a proper judgment.
Coach:
Jacques Martin:
A defensive style coach who hinders offensive player development. Good regular season results followed by playoff exits. Relies too heavily on goaltending in the playoffs and overuses certain players thereby rendering them ineffective come playoff time. Makes for a boring game to watch but he gets results, until playoff time. What’s with the too many men calls? (B-)
All told, the habs should finish in a playoff spot and fight Buffalo for second in the Northeast. I don’t think that they have the guns for a first place NE finish..
Happy season to you all!!
What do I know, I’m just a bus driver!
jimjim
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.